Cincinnati 2 - Chicago FC United

	1 - 2 (3 - 5 p.)
Cincinnati 2	18.03.2024 01:00 Ended after a penalty shootout	Chicago FC United

1st half
37'	Y. R. Perez
2nd half
			51'	J. Shannon
63'	Y. Valoyes
			65'	Harold Osorio
		0 - 1	71'	O. Glasgow (D. Borso)
74'	A. Daley	1 - 1
Extra time
		1 - 2
Penalty shootout
		0 - 1	1'	David Poreba
1'	P. Mangione	1 - 1
		1 - 2	2'	M. Nesci
2'	B. Schaefer
		1 - 3	3'	D. Konincks
3'	Y. R. Perez	2 - 3
		2 - 4	4'	O. Glasgow
4'	Isaiah Foster	3 - 4
		3 - 5	5'	R. Blake